Telewatcher > Science Fiction > Doctor Who

The Unicorn and the Wasp: Doctor Who Series Four Episode Seven

A review of Doctor Who Series Four Episode Seven. The Doctor and Donna find themselves in 1926 England and a murder mystery ensues.

Page 1 of 2 | Prev 12Next»

One wouldn't normally associate illegitimacy and homosexuality as themes - either major or minor - that a writer would choose when penning an episode of Doctor Who. It is a surprise that these themes should be countenanced in a show of this nature. However, this is what we got with the 1920s based murder mystery extravaganza, The Unicorn and the Wasp. Even more surprising is the revelation that these themes fit the series like a hand in to a glove.

The Doctor and Donna arrive just in time for a party at the home of Lady Edison (a still gorgeous Felicity Kendall). This gives Donna an opportunity to wear one of the many costume changes she hoisted on board the Tardis at the start of this series. She also gets to ask the delightful question "flapper or slapper?" - needless to say the Doctor errs on the side of caution in his response.

Conning their way in to the event with their usual aplomb and bare faced cheek they are both delighted to come face to face with Agatha Christie the then (and now) famous crime author. Just in the nick of time, too, for prior to their arrival a certain Colonel Plum was dispatched in the library with a piece of lead piping. There was, in addition, a moment for Lady Edison to mention (in a somewhat heavy handed moment of plot exposition) that there was a major jewel thief in the environs, known as the Unicorn.

Oh dear. So far, so “Cluedo” and I braced myself for the worst. Fortunately, Donna noticed this as well and pointed it out early on, so it was obvious that this would be more than a clumsy rip-off of the murder mystery genre. Taking the lead, the Doctor announces himself as Chief Inspector Smith from Scotland Yard and Donna as the “plucky girl” who helps him out. When Donna objects to this, he explains to her that at this period in time there were no female police officers in the force. Unfortunately, this was something of a historical gaffe and although the Doctor can make mistakes as we know, this should have been more thoroughly researched by the writer, Gareth Roberts.

Lilian Wiles was, in fact, the first female CID officer and she was appointed in 1922, four years before this episode takes place. It was not until 1973 that women were fully integrated in to the main force of the Metropolitan Police but the A4 Branch for female police officers was established by The Met in 1930. To ignore these important facts was an unforgivable mistake by the writer Gareth Roberts, considering the fact that it was omitted from history for such a throwaway line. It would have been far better to have said that peoples' expectations at the time were such that they would have been reluctant to accept a female police officer.

The guests are swiftly assembled in the drawing room and asked to explain their whereabouts at the time of the murders. The obligatory posh flapper, Miss Robina Redmond, explains herself. Unfortunately, her character is not given enough explanation Lady Edison simply says that she is the “absolute hit of the social scene” with no hint of where she may come from and so she comes immediately under suspicion. Other dubious explanations come from the Reverend Golightly (great name!) and Colonel Hugh Curbishley. This was hugely entertaining sequence, in which the characters say one thing about what they were doing and flashbacks comically reveal the not so savory truth of their real actions at the time.

Doctor Who has long had a huge gay fan base but until now has not had any overtly gay characters appear. I say overtly in case many readers of this review point out the character of Adric, who appeared with the Baker and Davison incarnations of the Doctor. Perhaps the writers had felt it was not necessary or even advisable in a programme aimed primarily at young children (and, ahem, gay men). Given the changes in times and culture, I guess it was only inevitable that at some point the writers would tip this section of their viewing community the wink. So, The Honorable Roger Curbishley, Lady Edison's son was seen giving one explanation of his whereabouts at the time of the murder. In fact he had been enjoying (a very innocent looking, hand-holding) liaison with his paramour, Davenport, one of the menservants of the household.

Despite the added assistance of Ms Christie, it is only a short time before Mrs Chandrakala, Lady Edison's companion and housekeeper becomes the second victim. Just before, Donna has a close encounter of the insect kind with what appears to be a giant wasp. This occurs in the bedroom in which Lady Edison spent six months recovering from Malaria forty years previously and which had been mysteriously sealed ever since.

Page 1 of 2 | Prev 12Next»
9
Liked It
I Like It!
Related Articles
The Poison Sky: Doctor Who Series Four Episode Five   |  Forest of the Dead: Doctor Who, Series Four, Episode Nine
More Articles by R J Evans
Journey's End: Doctor Who Series Four Episode 13  |  The Stolen Earth: Doctor Who Series 4 Episode 12
Latest Articles in Doctor Who
Doctor Who: Is Our Favorite Time Lord Running Out of Time?  |  Torchwood News Series 3
Comments (13)
#1 by Nick, May 18, 2008
The first gay moments of New Who are Jake in ROTC/The Age of Steel, although the scene which explicitly mentioned he and Ricky's more intimate side was vetoed by RTD, and the married lesbian sisters in 'Gridlock'.
#2 by John, May 18, 2008
An altogether positive review but let down by very poor research - go and find "The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances" then consider your comments on illegitimacy/homosexuality.
#3 by Marcos, May 19, 2008
Oh dear oh dear oh dear! Shocking episode, full of cringeworthy moments. This series has been a huge let down so far, with the exception of the Sontarans (just). Only Davros being resurrected in the finale will save the day now! The Daleks in Leeds!?! Oh please.
#4 by Marcos, May 19, 2008
...and in case you think I'm being unfair...one word: Adipose.
#5 by Emmikins, May 19, 2008
I have found an error in this doctor who episode
#6 by Dobbywobby, May 19, 2008
this episode ruled!
yeah, the first gay moments were in 'the empty child/the doctor dances', not here, but still.
loved this series! ok the adipose were rubbish and the pyrovile looked fake but the rest is brilliant. Catherine Tate is wonderful as Donna. i was a little aprihensive at first but she is brilliant.
can't wait for rose to come back
thought martha coming back was really well written
MORE FROM HELEN RAYNOR PLZ!!!
#7 by Fatfan, May 19, 2008
Wany an adipose for Christmas.... hehe
#8 by Ruby Hawk, May 19, 2008
Agatha Christy is my favorite author of all time but for the life of me I can't remember this book. I thought I had read everything she ever wrote, too.
#9 by The Black Guardian, May 20, 2008
You might be getting mixed up, Ruby. The Unicorn and the Wasp is an episoe of the UK TV Sci-Fi show "Doctor Who" which had Agatha Christie in as a character - it's not on eof her books!
#10 by Gawon, May 20, 2008
It was Professor Peach who was dispatched in the library with the lead pipe, not Colonel Plum.

When Donna makes mention of this in the style of Cluedo it is slightly inconsistent in that murderer's name would be mentioned, not the victim. This stood out for me perhaps a little more than it should have done :-) (I don't know how they would have been able to phrase this any other way, not knowing who the murderer was at the time.)

I also wouldn't quite go so far as to say that the 'policewomen in 1920s' mistake is 'unforgivable'. It didn't detract from the proceedings at all.
#11 by Chris, May 22, 2008
i loved this episode. Loved all the references to Agatha's books too. And Donna is fantastic. I wasn't looking fwd to her either, but she has been awesome to watch.
#12 by Llsewitch! , May 23, 2008
Felicity Kendal ROCKED! I mean really ROCKED! She is awsome. I did not really find Donna all that awsome, but I guess that it is cuz I am used to her being the sour teen Catherine Tate (Am I bofered?!) On the whole that episode was cool.
#13 by Llsewitch, May 23, 2008
Oh by the way...
I totally agree with "Chris". The references to all Agathas novels is cool!
Post Your Comment:
Name:  
Copy the code into this box:  
Post comment with your Triond credentials?
Inside Telewatcher

Action

 /

Animation

 /

Comedy

 /

Documentary

 /

Drama

 /

Game Shows

 /

News

 /

Reality

 /

Science Fiction

 /

Soap

 /

Talk Shows

 /

Telewatching


Popular Tags
Popular Writers
Powered by
Telewatcher
About Us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Services
Submit an Article
Advertise with Us
Contact

© 2007 Copyright Stanza Ltd. All Rights Reserved.